In the vast and beloved galaxy far, far away, the Star Wars saga has enthralled generations with its epic battles, compelling characters, and timeless themes of good versus evil. However, the sequel trilogy, comprising Episodes VII, VIII, and IX, has sparked considerable debate and controversy among fans. From narrative choices to character arcs, there are compelling reasons why some argue that this trilogy should be considered non-canon within the Star Wars universe.

1. Departure from Established Lore:

One of the primary concerns voiced by fans is the sequel trilogy's departure from established lore and continuity. Previous Star Wars material, including novels, comics, and even earlier films, established a rich tapestry of events, characters, and rules governing the galaxy. The sequel trilogy introduced new elements that contradicted or ignored existing lore, leading to inconsistencies and confusion among longtime fans.

For instance, the portrayal of the Force in the sequel trilogy, particularly the ability of characters like Rey to rapidly master its use without significant training, deviates from the established understanding of the Force as a mystical and disciplined practice. This departure undermined the internal logic of the Star Wars universe, leaving fans questioning the coherence of the narrative.

2. Characterization and Development Issues:

Another contentious issue revolves around the characterization and development of beloved legacy characters from the original trilogy. Characters like Luke Skywalker, Leia Organa, and Han Solo underwent significant changes that some fans argue were inconsistent with their established personalities and story arcs.

Luke Skywalker's portrayal as a disillusioned and isolated hermit in "The Last Jedi" particularly drew criticism for diverging from his hopeful and determined nature as seen in the original trilogy. Similarly, the handling of Leia's character after Carrie Fisher's passing in "The Rise of Skywalker" felt disjointed and forced, lacking the emotional depth and closure befitting such an iconic figure.

3. Narrative Incoherence and Pacing:

The sequel trilogy also faced criticism for its narrative structure, pacing issues, and perceived lack of cohesive planning across the three films. Unlike the original trilogy, which was meticulously planned and executed under George Lucas's vision, the sequel trilogy saw different directors with varying interpretations and visions for the story.

This lack of overarching direction resulted in plot threads that were introduced and dropped abruptly, unresolved character arcs, and an overall sense of disjointed storytelling. Key plot points introduced in one film often seemed hastily resolved or disregarded in the next, leading to a narrative that felt unsatisfying and incomplete.

4. Fan Dissatisfaction and Cultural Impact:

Beyond the narrative and creative aspects, the sequel trilogy's reception among fans has had a profound cultural impact. The divisive nature of these films has led to significant polarization within the Star Wars community, with debates raging over the artistic integrity of the storytelling and the handling of beloved characters.

While some fans embraced the sequel trilogy for its visual spectacle and introduction of new characters, others felt disillusioned by what they perceived as a betrayal of the core values and mythology that defined Star Wars for them. This discontent has spurred discussions about the role of fan expectations versus creative freedom in shaping the future of beloved franchises.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, while the sequel trilogy brought new stories and characters into the Star Wars universe, its departure from established lore, characterization issues, narrative coherence problems, and fan dissatisfaction have led many to question its status as canon. The debate over whether these films should be considered non-canon reflects a desire among fans for storytelling that honors the legacy and spirit of the original trilogy while pushing the boundaries of creativity and imagination.

As the Star Wars saga continues to evolve through new films, series, and expanded universe content, the legacy of the sequel trilogy serves as a reminder of the challenges and responsibilities inherent in expanding upon beloved storytelling universes. Ultimately, the decision of canon status rests with Lucasfilm and the storytellers entrusted with shaping the future of Star Wars, as they navigate the delicate balance between honoring the past and forging new paths for the galaxy far, far away.